Difference between revisions of "Ambient vibration array"

From GeopsyWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(104 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
 
== Common pre-requisites for array processing - getting ready ==
 
== Common pre-requisites for array processing - getting ready ==
  
=== Loading signals ===
+
For any array processing of ambient vibration data there are some
 +
common steps / pre-requisites regarding your signal recordings (selection
 +
of simultaneous recordings, coordinate insertion, signal grouping).
 +
Learn about all these options/preparatory steps in the following
 +
sub-chapters (linking to other parts of this wiki)
  
=== View time series ===
+
=== Loading and viewing signals (time series) ===
  
=== Group signals ===
+
Before processing your ambient vibration data, you need to [[Loading and viewing signals|load your signal files]]
 +
into geopsy and build a database. For checking the data quality of recordings and potential timing
 +
problems while recording you might want to use the [[Geopsy: Graphic|graphic viewer]] and the [[Geopsy: Chronogram|chronogram viewer]].
 +
It is often also a good idea to compute [[Spectral_amplitudes|Spectra]] and or [[H/V_spectral_ratio|H/V spectral ratios]] (in case of 3C data) from your
 +
recordings to check the spectral energy content, problematic installations and ''1-D-ness'' of your region.
  
=== Insert / edit station coordinates ===
+
links to [[Loading_and_viewing_signals|loading and viewing signals]]
  
== F-K Toolbox (conventional f-k) ==
+
=== Group signals ===
  
[[Image:LepRing01OnlyVertical.png|thumb|right|400px|Signal viewer for one group of simultaneously recorded waveforms ready for array processing]]
+
An array is defined by grouping a set of stations with common time base and recording simultaneously the properties
 +
of the wavefield at different, but closely co-located positions in space. After having built a database with many recordings, you may
 +
group individual arrays from the full set of signals. Both single component and three component arrays can be bundled
 +
together causing the array processing toolboxes to work on single or three component data, respectively.
  
If you have followed all steps above you should have now a set of simultaneously recorded waveforms
+
For details on how to group signals for array processing take a look in [[Geopsy: Groups|groups]]
building a group and containing coordinates for each waveform. You can view this group of waveforms in the
 
data viewer and should get a picture like the one shown to the right.
 
  
Now you can open the conventional frequency wavenumber toolbox by pushing the plugin icon [[Image:FKToolboxPluginIcon.png|32px]].
+
=== Insert / edit station coordinates ===
  
The f-k toolbox should open and is now attached to the [[Geopsy: Signal Viewer|signal viewer]]. No other toolbox will now open with
+
The final step in the preparation of your data set consists in attaching the stations coordinates to your
the signals you have loaded to the signal viewer. In order to process the same data set by another
+
recordings. Note that some [[Geopsy:_Supported_file_formats|waveform formats]] store the station coordinates and are eventually already included
tool, you have to open them in a different signal viewer window. Note also, that once you close either
+
while importing the signal files. For most formats, however, this will be not the case. So, prepare you coordinate information
the f-k toolbox window or the signal viewer, there is no way to undo this action - you will have to start
+
from yor field book or your measurement devices (theodulite / (D)GPS device / etc.) and prepare some [[SciFigs: Multi-column Parser|multi-column ASCII file]]
again by opening a new signal viewer and attaching the f-k toolbox to it. Alternatively you can drag your
+
which can be read into [[geopsy]]. Details how to set coordinates can be found in section [[Geopsy: Set receivers|set receivers]]
group directly into the f-k toolbox icon. Geopsy will automatically open a new exclusively attached signal viewer
 
for you. 
 
  
<br style="clear: both"/>
 
  
[[Image:FKToolboxTimeTab.png|thumb|left|300px|Conventional f-k toolbox]]
+
Since July 2018, high resolution and conventional FK toolboxes have been merged into a single FK toolbox. The text below should be reworked.
  
Let's now have a close look to the individual parameters to be set in the f-k toolbox. There are four
+
FK processing can be achieved inside Geopsy graphical interface or through a command line [[geopsy-fk]].
main groups of parameters to be considered.
 
  
* Pre-processing parameters for excluding data from processing.
+
== F-K Toolbox (conventional f-k) ==
* Processing parameters for selecting time windows on the remaining data.
 
* Processing parameters for selecting narrow frequency bands for processing
 
* Parameters related to the output of results from f-k processing.
 
  
These parameters are laid out in different parts of the f-k toolbox widget.
+
The conventional frequency wavenumber technique as implemented in '''Geopsy''' is based
Note, that the toolbox has three main tabs: ''Time'', ''Processing'' and ''Status''.  
+
on the simple idea of [[Wikipedia:Sensor array#Delay-and-sum_beamforming|''delay and sum'' (or ''shift and sum'')]].
 +
This technique may be effectuated equivalently in time domain or frequency domain.
 +
In Geopsy we follow the frequency domain approach, as it is the most convenient and effective
 +
way to use this approach for determination of frequency dependent apparent velocity estimation
 +
(i.e dispersion curve estimation under the assumption of the wave field being composed of
 +
surface waves only).  
  
The pre-processing parameters for excluding data from processing follow the same argumentation as the  
+
The simultaneous waveform recordings of a group of spatially distributed stations are analyzed
data selection for other toolboxes like [[Geopsy: HV Toolbox|H/V processing]] and can be found in the
+
in many narrow (mostly overlapping) frequency bands for individual analysis windows cut from the
''Time tab''.  
+
overall recordings. For each analysis window and frequency band, a grid search is performed
 +
in the wavenumber domain to effectively find the propagation properties of the most coherent
 +
and/or powerful plane wave arrival in the analysis window. Given the assumption of surface
 +
waves dominating the wave field, the apparent velocity equals the phase velocity of the
 +
surface wave at this particular frequency.
  
E.g. one can apply the so-called [[Geopsy: Anti Trigger|anti-trigger]]
+
Details of the signal processing can be found in the [[Array signal processing|array signal processing]]  
approach for removing transient signals from the continuous recordings (i.e. excluding those time chunks from
+
page of this wiki or following one of the links below in section [[#See also|see also]]
processing). The anti-trigger approach can be applied to raw or filtered data. For the detailed
 
settings please look into the description of [[Geopsy: Anti Trigger|anti-trigger]].
 
Another, second, approach for excluding data from processing is provided via the [[Geopsy: Bad sample|bad sample]] approach.
 
For details in setting parameters with the bad sample approach check [[Geopsy: Bad sample|this page]].
 
  
There are two distinct inputs in the f-k toolbox for selecting time windows for processing.
+
For learning about the detailed use of the f-k toolbox (geopsy plugin) in a tutorial like fashion, please [[FK|follow this link to FK]].
First, it is necessary to specify start and end times of the overall data window for processing
 
by selecting entries ''From'' and ''To'' in the ''Time limits'' part of the ''Time tab'' of the fk-toolbox
 
[[Image:FKTimeLimits.png|250px]].  
 
  
There are three options each for the
+
== High resolution frequency wavenumber Toolbox (Capon's method) ==
drop boxes ''From'' and ''To''. For the ''From'' entry you can select among [[Image:FKFromDropList.png|100px]].
 
  
* this time (entries in form xx '''h''' xx '''m''' xx.xxx '''s''')
+
The high resolution frequency wavenumber (hrfk) algorithm can be viewed as a '''''generalized''''' beamforming algorithm. It is implemented in '''Geopsy''' following the ideas of Capon (1969)  
* T0 (selects earliest common start time of all traces in group)
+
<ref name="Capon (1969)"> Capon, J., High-Resolution Frequency-Wavenumber Spectrum Analysis, Proceedings of the IEEE, 57, No. 8, 1408-1419, 1969.</ref>,
* during (selects time duration before end of the signals - either specified with ''End'' or ''this time'' as explained below)
+
using an auto-adaptive (optimal) complex spatial weighting scheme for analysis of narrowband stationary signals. It is one of the most common and preferred frequency wavenumber techniques applied to
 +
ambient vibration analysis. 
  
For the ''To'' entry there are the options [[Image:FKToDropList.png|100px]]:
+
The Capon beamformer relies on a very simple formula:
  
* this time (entries in form xx '''h''' xx '''m''' xx.xxx '''s''')
+
<math>
* End (selects latest common end time of all traces in group)
+
BP_{Capon}(\omega,\vec{k}) = \frac{1}{\vec{e}^\dagger(\omega,\vec{k})\underline{R}^{-1}(\omega)\vec{e}(\omega,\vec{k})}
* during (selects time duration from start time as given above - either specified by ''this time'' or ''T0'')
+
</math>
  
Note: a selection of time limits as ''From: during'' && ''To: during'' is NOT valid.
+
where <math>\underline{R}^{-1}(\omega)</math> is simply the inverse of the cross spectral matrix estimate and <math>\vec{e}</math>
 +
is the so-called steering vector summarizing the shift times for the harmonic plane wave with wavenumber vector <math>\vec{k}</math>
 +
for each station within the array.The <math>\dagger</math> symbol presents the conjugate transpose operation. In the same notation,
 +
the conventional f-k algorithm would be formulated as:
  
[[Image:FKGeneralTab.png|thumb|left|300px|General tab]]
+
<math>
After selecting the overall data window for processing you finally have to specify the window length for  
+
BP_{conv.}(\omega,\vec{k}) = \vec{e}^\dagger(\omega,\vec{k})\underline{R}(\omega)\vec{e}(\omega,\vec{k})
each single analysis window to be processed. You can find this ''length'' parameter in the ''General'' tab inside the
+
</math>
''Time tab''.
+
 +
The required computation of the inverse of the cross-spectral matrix results in some potential instabilities for the HRFK estimates.
  
 +
The corresponding toolbox can be opened using the icon [[Image:HRFKPluginIcon.png|32px]]. It is nearly equivalent to the [[FK|conventional frequency wavenumber]]
 +
toolbox and the processing flow is exactly equivalent to the conventional technique.
  
Processing parameters for selecting the time windows on the remaining data
+
For learning about the detailed use of the HRFK toolbox (geopsy plugin) in a tutorial like fashion, please [[HRFK| follow this link to HRFK]]
  
<br style="clear: both"/>
+
== Modified Spatial Autocorrelation (MSPAC) Toolbox ==
  
 +
The Modified Spatial Autocorrelation (MSPAC) was introduced by Bettig et al. (2001) <ref name="Bettig et al. (2001)"> Bettig B., P.-Y. Bard, F. Scherbaum, J. Riepl, F. Cotton, C. Cornou, D. Hatzfeld, 2001. Analysis of dense array measurements using the modified spatial auto-correlation method (SPAC). Application to Grenoble area., Boletin de Geofisica Teoria e Applicata, 42, 3-4, 281-304.</ref> after pioneer paper of Aki (1957)<ref name="Aki (1957)."> Aki, K., 1957. Space and Time Spectra of Stationary Stochastic Waves, with Special Reference to Microtremors, Bull. Earthq. Res. Inst. Tokyo, 35, 415-457. </ref> and allows to compute average spatial autocorrelation coefficients for any arbitary array configurations. As SPAC technique, MSPAC relies on a stochastic ambient noise wavefield stationary in both time and space. Aki (1957) showed, that, given this assumption, the existing relation between the spectrum densities in space and time can be used to derive the following expression for a plane wave narrow-band filtered around <math>\omega_0</math>:
  
=== Saving results / contents of output file ===
+
<math>
 +
\overline{\rho(\omega_0 , r)} = \frac{1}{\pi}\int^{0}_{\pi}\rho(\omega_0,r,\varphi)d(\varphi)= J_0(\frac{\omega r}{c(\omega_0)})
 +
</math>
  
=== Graphical display of f-k results using max2curve ===
+
<math>\overline{\rho(\omega_0 , r)}</math> represents the averaging over azimuth of spatial autocorrelations  <math> {\rho(\omega_0 , r, \varphi)} = cos(\frac{\omega_0 r}{c(\omega_0)}cos(\theta-\varphi)) </math> where <math>{\theta}</math> is the wave azimuth and <math>{\varphi}</math> the direction azimuth between stations pairs. 
  
[[max2curve]]
 
  
== High resolution frequency wavenumber Toolbox (Capon's method) ==
 
  
=== Saving results / contents of output file ===
+
Application of the SPAC technique (as well as further derived techniques like ESAC) requires perfect shaped arrays (circular, semi-circular, nested triangles) which may be difficult to achieve in urban environment. To overcome these difficulties, Bettig et al. (2001) <ref name="Bettig et al. (2001)"> Bettig B., P.-Y. Bard, F. Scherbaum, J. Riepl, F. Cotton, C. Cornou, D. Hatzfeld, 2001. Analysis of dense array measurements using the modified spatial auto-correlation method (SPAC). Application to Grenoble area., Boletin de Geofisica Teoria e Applicata, 42, 3-4, 281-304.</ref> suggested to use the co-array - which is defined as the set of all possible combinations of two array sensors (Haubrich, 1968 <ref name="Haubrich (1968)"> Haubrich, R.A., 1968. Array Design, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 58(3), 977–991. </ref>) - to divide the array into several semicircular sub-arrays. Each sub-array (hereafter called ring) is thus composed of several sensors pairs. To account for ring thickness, an azimuthal and radial integration is then needed to compute averaged spatial autocorrelation values <ref name="Bettig et al. (2001)"> Bettig B., P.-Y. Bard, F. Scherbaum, J. Riepl, F. Cotton, C. Cornou, D. Hatzfeld, 2001. Analysis of dense array measurements using the modified spatial auto-correlation method (SPAC). Application to Grenoble area., Boletin de Geofisica Teoria e Applicata, 42, 3-4, 281-304.</ref>:
  
=== Graphical display of f-k results using max2curve ===
+
<math>
 +
\overline{\rho_{r_1,r_2}(\omega)} = \frac{2}{r_2^2-r_1^2} \int^{r_1}_{r_2}r.J_0(\frac{\omega r}{c(\omega)})dr = \frac{2}{r_2^2-r_1^2}\frac{c(\omega)}{\omega}[r.J_1(\frac{\omega r}{c(\omega)})]^{r_1}_{r_2}
 +
</math>
  
== Modified Spatial Autocorrelation (MSPAC) Toolbox ==
+
where <math> r_1 </math> and <math> r_2 </math> are the inner and outer radius of the ring, respectively.
 
 
The Modified Spatial Autocorrelation (MSPAC) was introduced by Bettig et al. (2001) <ref name="Bettig et al. (2001)"> Bettig B., P.-Y. Bard, F. Scherbaum, J. Riepl, F. Cotton, C. Cornou, D. Hatzfeld, 2001. Analysis of dense array measurements using the modified spatial auto-correlation method (SPAC). Application to Grenoble area., Boletin de Geofisica Teoria e Applicata, 42, 3-4, 281-304.</ref> after pioneer paper of Aki (1957). <ref name="Aki (1957)."> Aki, K., 1957. Space and Time Spectra of Stationary Stochastic Waves, with Special Reference to Microtremors, Bull. Earthq. Res. Inst. Tokyo, 35, 415-457. </ref> This method allows computing spatial autocorrelation coefficients for any arbitary array layouts.
 
 
 
After viewing the group of waveforms in the data viewer, open the MSPAC toolbox by pushing the following plugin icon  [[Image:SPACToolboxPluginIcon.png|32px]]. Alternatively you can drag your group directly into the SPAC toolbox icon. The SPAC toolbox should now be attached to the signal viewer.
 
 
 
[[Image:LepRing01OnlyVertical_SPAC_VIEWALL.png|thumb|right|400px]]
 
Four windows should then opened as displayed in the figure on the right: (1) a signal time viewer, (2) a map displaying array station locations, (3) a map displaying co-array stations location and (4) the SPAC processing toolbox. This processing toolbox is composed of four sub-menus: "Rings" sub-menu is used to design rings from the co-array; "Time" is used to define begin and end time to be processed, time window length, anti-triggering options as described in section XXX; "Output" menu is used to set up the output frequency band together with the sampling scale type (linear, log) and number of frequencies, the output filename; "Status" menu provides information about computing status. All these sub-menus are described hereafter.
 
 
 
=== Defining rings ===
 
 
 
[[Image:LepRing01OnlyVertical_SPAC_SELECT_RINGS_FIRST_STEP.png|thumb|right|400px]]
 
  
 +
This method allows computing spatial autocorrelation coefficients for any arbitary array configurations. The design of rings results from a compromise between a number of sensors pair per ring as large as possible and a ring thickness as small as possible.
  
  
=== Saving results / contents of output file ===
+
For learning the usage of the MSPAC Toolbox in detail in a tutorial like fashion, please [[MSPAC| follow this link to MSPAC]].
  
=== Graphical display of f-k results using spac2disp ===
+
== See also ==
  
spac2disp
+
* [[Wikipedia:Array_signal_processing|Wikipedia page on array signal processing]]
 +
* [http://www.geopsy.org geopsy.org]
 +
* etc.
  
=== References ===
+
== References ==
 
<references/>
 
<references/>
 
== Further readings ==
 
 
* [[Frequency Wavenumber]]
 
* [[High Resolution Frequency Wavenumber]]
 

Latest revision as of 07:37, 10 July 2018


Common pre-requisites for array processing - getting ready

For any array processing of ambient vibration data there are some common steps / pre-requisites regarding your signal recordings (selection of simultaneous recordings, coordinate insertion, signal grouping). Learn about all these options/preparatory steps in the following sub-chapters (linking to other parts of this wiki)

Loading and viewing signals (time series)

Before processing your ambient vibration data, you need to load your signal files into geopsy and build a database. For checking the data quality of recordings and potential timing problems while recording you might want to use the graphic viewer and the chronogram viewer. It is often also a good idea to compute Spectra and or H/V spectral ratios (in case of 3C data) from your recordings to check the spectral energy content, problematic installations and 1-D-ness of your region.

links to loading and viewing signals

Group signals

An array is defined by grouping a set of stations with common time base and recording simultaneously the properties of the wavefield at different, but closely co-located positions in space. After having built a database with many recordings, you may group individual arrays from the full set of signals. Both single component and three component arrays can be bundled together causing the array processing toolboxes to work on single or three component data, respectively.

For details on how to group signals for array processing take a look in groups

Insert / edit station coordinates

The final step in the preparation of your data set consists in attaching the stations coordinates to your recordings. Note that some waveform formats store the station coordinates and are eventually already included while importing the signal files. For most formats, however, this will be not the case. So, prepare you coordinate information from yor field book or your measurement devices (theodulite / (D)GPS device / etc.) and prepare some multi-column ASCII file which can be read into geopsy. Details how to set coordinates can be found in section set receivers


Since July 2018, high resolution and conventional FK toolboxes have been merged into a single FK toolbox. The text below should be reworked.

FK processing can be achieved inside Geopsy graphical interface or through a command line geopsy-fk.

F-K Toolbox (conventional f-k)

The conventional frequency wavenumber technique as implemented in Geopsy is based on the simple idea of delay and sum (or shift and sum). This technique may be effectuated equivalently in time domain or frequency domain. In Geopsy we follow the frequency domain approach, as it is the most convenient and effective way to use this approach for determination of frequency dependent apparent velocity estimation (i.e dispersion curve estimation under the assumption of the wave field being composed of surface waves only).

The simultaneous waveform recordings of a group of spatially distributed stations are analyzed in many narrow (mostly overlapping) frequency bands for individual analysis windows cut from the overall recordings. For each analysis window and frequency band, a grid search is performed in the wavenumber domain to effectively find the propagation properties of the most coherent and/or powerful plane wave arrival in the analysis window. Given the assumption of surface waves dominating the wave field, the apparent velocity equals the phase velocity of the surface wave at this particular frequency.

Details of the signal processing can be found in the array signal processing page of this wiki or following one of the links below in section see also

For learning about the detailed use of the f-k toolbox (geopsy plugin) in a tutorial like fashion, please follow this link to FK.

High resolution frequency wavenumber Toolbox (Capon's method)

The high resolution frequency wavenumber (hrfk) algorithm can be viewed as a generalized beamforming algorithm. It is implemented in Geopsy following the ideas of Capon (1969) [1], using an auto-adaptive (optimal) complex spatial weighting scheme for analysis of narrowband stationary signals. It is one of the most common and preferred frequency wavenumber techniques applied to ambient vibration analysis.

The Capon beamformer relies on a very simple formula:

where is simply the inverse of the cross spectral matrix estimate and is the so-called steering vector summarizing the shift times for the harmonic plane wave with wavenumber vector for each station within the array.The symbol presents the conjugate transpose operation. In the same notation, the conventional f-k algorithm would be formulated as:

The required computation of the inverse of the cross-spectral matrix results in some potential instabilities for the HRFK estimates.

The corresponding toolbox can be opened using the icon HRFKPluginIcon.png. It is nearly equivalent to the conventional frequency wavenumber toolbox and the processing flow is exactly equivalent to the conventional technique.

For learning about the detailed use of the HRFK toolbox (geopsy plugin) in a tutorial like fashion, please follow this link to HRFK

Modified Spatial Autocorrelation (MSPAC) Toolbox

The Modified Spatial Autocorrelation (MSPAC) was introduced by Bettig et al. (2001) [2] after pioneer paper of Aki (1957)[3] and allows to compute average spatial autocorrelation coefficients for any arbitary array configurations. As SPAC technique, MSPAC relies on a stochastic ambient noise wavefield stationary in both time and space. Aki (1957) showed, that, given this assumption, the existing relation between the spectrum densities in space and time can be used to derive the following expression for a plane wave narrow-band filtered around :

represents the averaging over azimuth of spatial autocorrelations where is the wave azimuth and the direction azimuth between stations pairs.


Application of the SPAC technique (as well as further derived techniques like ESAC) requires perfect shaped arrays (circular, semi-circular, nested triangles) which may be difficult to achieve in urban environment. To overcome these difficulties, Bettig et al. (2001) [2] suggested to use the co-array - which is defined as the set of all possible combinations of two array sensors (Haubrich, 1968 [4]) - to divide the array into several semicircular sub-arrays. Each sub-array (hereafter called ring) is thus composed of several sensors pairs. To account for ring thickness, an azimuthal and radial integration is then needed to compute averaged spatial autocorrelation values [2]:

where and are the inner and outer radius of the ring, respectively.

This method allows computing spatial autocorrelation coefficients for any arbitary array configurations. The design of rings results from a compromise between a number of sensors pair per ring as large as possible and a ring thickness as small as possible.


For learning the usage of the MSPAC Toolbox in detail in a tutorial like fashion, please follow this link to MSPAC.

See also

References

  1. Capon, J., High-Resolution Frequency-Wavenumber Spectrum Analysis, Proceedings of the IEEE, 57, No. 8, 1408-1419, 1969.
  2. 2.0 2.1 2.2 Bettig B., P.-Y. Bard, F. Scherbaum, J. Riepl, F. Cotton, C. Cornou, D. Hatzfeld, 2001. Analysis of dense array measurements using the modified spatial auto-correlation method (SPAC). Application to Grenoble area., Boletin de Geofisica Teoria e Applicata, 42, 3-4, 281-304.
  3. Aki, K., 1957. Space and Time Spectra of Stationary Stochastic Waves, with Special Reference to Microtremors, Bull. Earthq. Res. Inst. Tokyo, 35, 415-457.
  4. Haubrich, R.A., 1968. Array Design, Bull. seism. Soc. Am., 58(3), 977–991.